Rest in peace, John Dierker.
I’d only met John a couple times in Baltimore, both times playing music. John was an extraordinary sax/clarinet player. The second time I saw him we shared a bill at Le Comptoir du Vin and played one of the best sets of my life. John and I also had what for me was a very affirming conversation about work-life-art balance. I’m not really a public mourner and didn’t know him well, but I am thinking about him deeply today.
My heart will always be warmed by the fact that John’s daughter Ida Dierker is an incredible pianist—I imagine her father was an influence—and that they have performed together. Meaningful father-daughter relationships are my absolute favorite narrative. I’m heartbroken for Ida.
Heartbreak.
I ran into a past employer at an event, with whom I made some small-ish talk before she gently pulled me in to share a secret. I need to tell you something before we get bombarded.
“You broke my heart, you know.”
My eyes became alert as I stared into hers. I can’t share what I felt either because it was too banal or too complex. I simply heard her, the act of a molecular reception of a radiated transmission. And because this was a packed event and sound enveloped us in powers of ten, we were pulled into other conversations in waves of volume with other people talking about their lives lately and what one was wearing.
Heartbreak is now a dialectic. A relief to get to this point, frankly. If I’m trying to avoid someone, I’d use the word heartbreak to describe the feeling being around them arouses. I’d rather describe the heartbreak than the act of avoiding, then. Heartbreak can encompass humiliation, but it is preferable to being oblivious to the embarrassment of intellectualizing the feeling; rather than describing the physical act of avoidance with internecine rationalizations of consequences to claiming stakes with too much specificity, of dealings that aren’t closed, of wrongdoing. I am proud of knowing that I am embarrassed. I will allow me to hold on to this little avoidance forever.
Heartbreak because maternal maturity means hearing “I hate your guts” from a child and thinking “wow he can mirror” instead of believing him, and heartbreak because mysteries are cheap entertainment. How did you put it? I can’t wait for you to finish reading the book I told you was the skeleton key to me. That can break, too.
The grief being felt by those who mourn John will hold the warmth of his contributions to music and for some like me, the symbolism (also the reality) of his collaboration with Ida, his daughter. This is the dualism I want. Processing the effect of a lost person into a held personage so it is no longer distance from feeling that I seek but the ability to pull someone aside at a party and tell them the secret, too.

